Playbooks / Her Back Post-Cheating

How to Get Her Back When You Cheated?

April 2025

You cheated.

Now you want her back.

Let me be direct: This is the hardest breakup to reverse.

Not impossible. But the hardest.

Because you didn't just lose her trust. You shattered it.

And trust, once broken like that, takes more than apologies to rebuild.

It takes time. Consistency. Complete transparency.

And even then, she might never come back.

But if you're serious — if you genuinely want to do this right — here's how.

Why This Is Different

Most breakups happen because of incompatibility, arguments, or drifting apart.

Those can be fixed with space, growth, and reconnection.

But infidelity?

That's a violation. A betrayal. A fundamental breach.

You didn't just hurt her feelings. You destroyed her sense of safety with you.

Every relationship has an unspoken contract:

"We're on the same team. We protect each other. We don't betray each other."

You broke that contract.

And now she's questioning everything:

  • Was anything real?
  • How long has this been going on?
  • What else did you lie about?
  • Can I ever trust you again?
  • Can I ever trust anyone again?

You're not just fighting to win her back.

You're fighting against every doubt, every replay of what you did, every moment she imagines you with someone else.

That's the reality.

And if you can't handle that, stop reading now.

The Brutal Truth About Your Chances

Let's be honest about the odds.

Most relationships don't survive infidelity.

Not because love isn't there. But because trust is gone.

And without trust, love becomes torture.

She might still care about you. She might even still love you.

But every time she looks at you, she'll remember what you did.

Every time you're late coming home, she'll wonder.

Every time you're on your phone, she'll feel sick.

That's what you're asking her to sign up for if she takes you back.

So before you try to win her back, ask yourself:

Are you willing to earn her trust back? For months? Maybe years?

Complete transparency. No privacy on your phone. Checking in constantly. Answering questions you've already answered a hundred times.

If that sounds exhausting or unfair, you're not ready.

Because that's what rebuilding trust after infidelity looks like.

Still here? Okay. Let's talk about how to do this right.

Step 1: Give Her Space

Give her space. She's hurt and angry.

This is non-negotiable.

Right after she finds out, her emotions are chaotic:

  • Rage
  • Devastation
  • Humiliation
  • Disbelief
  • Self-blame

She can't think clearly. And neither can you.

Let her process these emotions alone.

She's asking herself questions like:

  • "How long has this been going on?"
  • "Was I not enough?"
  • "Can I ever trust again?"
  • "What's wrong with me?"

You can't answer these questions for her right now. Your presence just makes it worse.

How long?

Give her 2-4+ weeks of no contact. Minimum.

Maybe longer if:

  • The affair was long-term (not a one-time mistake)
  • She found out from someone else (not from you)
  • You lied when confronted (made it worse)

Use the no contact rule as your foundation here.

But understand: This isn't no contact to "make her miss you."

This is no contact because she needs space to breathe without you triggering her pain constantly.

What if she keeps reaching out?

If she contacts you — to yell, to ask questions, to cry — respond.

But keep it brief. Honest. Remorseful.

Don't try to "fix" things yet. Just be there if she needs to rage or grieve.

More on this: What to do if you're still texting your ex.

Step 2: Stay Away From Other Women

Don't make things worse by fuelling her anger.

This should be obvious. But I'm saying it anyway.

Do not:

  • See the person you cheated with (cut them off completely)
  • Date anyone else
  • Hook up with anyone
  • Flirt with anyone
  • Post anything on social media that looks remotely like you're moving on

If she sees or hears about you with another woman — any woman — it's over.

She'll interpret it as: "He didn't even care. He just moved on."

Even if that's not what you meant.

Your social life needs to be monk-level boring right now.

Work. Gym. Home. Maybe close friends.

That's it.

No bars. No parties. No situations where you could be seen with women.

This isn't forever. Just until you've proven you're serious.

Step 3: Be Honest With Yourself

Why did you cheat?

Not the surface reason. The real reason.

Most guys say:

  • "I was drunk"
  • "It just happened"
  • "She came onto me"
  • "I don't know why I did it"

That's not good enough.

Dig deeper.

Common underlying reasons:

Insecurity. You needed validation. Proof you're still attractive or desirable.

Lack of admiration. You didn't feel respected or valued in the relationship. So you sought it elsewhere.

Emotional distance. The relationship felt stale. You weren't connecting. You were lonely even with her.

Immaturity. You wanted the thrill. The newness. The ego boost.

Selfishness. You wanted what you wanted and didn't think about consequences.

Revenge. She hurt you (real or perceived). You wanted to hurt her back.

Opportunity. You had the chance and you took it. No deeper reason than that.

Understanding this helps prevent future mistakes.

If you don't know why you did it, you can't fix the problem.

And if you can't fix the problem, she has no reason to trust you won't do it again.

Be brutally honest with yourself. Write it down if you have to.

This work isn't for her. It's for you.

More on this: Was it my fault? — understanding your role in relationship problems.

Step 4: Take Responsibility

Own your actions. Don't make excuses.

This is where most guys fail.

They say things like:

  • "You were always working. I felt neglected."
  • "We weren't even having sex anymore."
  • "She was flirting with me. I couldn't help it."
  • "You pushed me away."

Stop.

Those might be context. But they're not justification.

Taking responsibility means:

Acknowledging your role.

"I cheated. That was my choice. My decision. My fault."

Not blaming her.

Even if the relationship had problems, cheating was your response. Not hers.

Not blaming circumstances.

Being drunk, stressed, lonely — those are reasons you were vulnerable. Not reasons you get a pass.

Learning from it.

What will you do differently? How will you handle those feelings next time?

Changing your behavior.

Words mean nothing without action.

If you cheated because you were drinking too much? Stop drinking.

If you cheated because you put yourself in tempting situations? Stop putting yourself in those situations.

If you cheated because you weren't communicating your needs? Learn to communicate.

Real accountability isn't "I'm sorry."

It's "I'm sorry, here's why it happened, here's what I've learned, and here's how I'm changing."

Step 5: Apologize Sincerely

Show genuine remorse. Feel her pain.

When you do apologize — in person, if possible, or in a letter — make it count.

Bad apology:

"I'm sorry I hurt you. I was stupid. It didn't mean anything. Can we move on?"

Why it fails: Minimizes the impact. Asks for forgiveness before earning it.

Good apology:

"I'm sorry. I know 'sorry' doesn't fix what I did. I betrayed you. I broke your trust. I hurt you in a way I can't take back. You didn't deserve that. I understand if you can't forgive me. I just need you to know how deeply I regret it."

Why it works: Focuses on her pain, not your guilt. Doesn't ask for anything. Just owns it.

Don't justify your actions.

"It didn't mean anything" sounds like you're downplaying it.

To her, it means: "You destroyed me over nothing."

That's worse.

Do show you understand the impact.

"I know I made you question everything. I know you're replaying every moment wondering what else I lied about. I know I made you feel like you weren't enough. I'm so sorry."

That lands. Because it shows you get it.

More on effective apologies: How to break down emotional walls.

Step 6: Forgive Yourself

You can't move forward if you're stuck in guilt.

This one's tricky.

You need to feel remorse. But you can't drown in it.

If you're constantly beating yourself up, you'll be useless to her and to yourself.

Forgiving yourself doesn't mean:

  • What you did was okay
  • You get to move on without consequences
  • She has to forgive you too

It means:

  • You accept what you did
  • You commit to being better
  • You don't let shame paralyze you

Guilt is useful when it motivates change.

Shame is toxic when it keeps you stuck.

Know the difference.

If you're struggling with this, consider therapy. Seriously.

Infidelity often reveals deeper issues that need professional help.

Step 7: Prove You've Changed

Actions speak louder than words. Show her you're trustworthy.

This is the long game.

You can't prove change in a week. Or a month.

This takes consistent action over months.

What "proving change" looks like:

Complete transparency.

She gets access to your phone. Your social media. Your location.

No locked apps. No "I need my privacy."

You gave up privacy when you cheated.

Cutting off the person you cheated with.

Completely. Blocked. No exceptions.

If you work with them, you tell HR and request no overlap.

Being where you say you'll be.

If you say you're going to the gym, you're at the gym.

She shouldn't have to wonder. Ever.

Checking in.

Text her when you arrive places. When you leave. Who you're with.

It might feel like overkill. But it's necessary.

This might mean cutting back on drinking or being punctual to rebuild trust.

If alcohol was involved in the cheating, stop drinking.

If staying out late was part of the pattern, come home early.

Remove the conditions that led to the betrayal.

Consistency over time.

One week of good behavior means nothing.

Three months? That's progress.

Six months? That's when she starts to breathe again.

A year? That's when trust starts to rebuild.

Don't expect quick wins here.

Step 8: Accept Her Decision

She might not want you back. Be okay with that.

This is the hardest one.

You might do everything right and she still walks away.

Because forgiveness is her choice. Not your right.

She doesn't owe you another chance.

Even if you've changed. Even if you're sorry. Even if you'd never do it again.

She gets to decide if she can live with what you did.

And if she can't, you have to respect that.

Paradoxically, accepting her decision might make her more open to talking.

When you're not pressuring her, begging her, making it about your need for forgiveness...

She has space to consider whether she wants to try again.

Desperation repels. Dignity attracts.

Even in this situation.

More on this mindset: Posture over outcome.

Step 9: Spend Time Together Without Romance

Rebuild your connection slowly.

If she agrees to see you, don't rush.

Don't try to kiss her. Don't try to hold her hand.

Don't even try to talk about "us" yet.

Just: be together.

Go for walks. Grab coffee. Play sports together.

Activities where you're doing something besides talking about the relationship.

This serves two purposes:

It creates new positive associations.

Right now, every memory of you is tainted by the betrayal.

You need new memories. Clean ones.

It lets her feel safe around you again.

Without pressure. Without expectations.

Just: "Maybe he's not a monster. Maybe we can be okay."

That's the foundation you're rebuilding.

More on reconnection: Effective ways to reconnect.

Step 10: Start Fresh

If she gives you another chance, treat it like a new relationship.

This isn't picking up where you left off.

That relationship is dead. You killed it.

This is a new relationship. Built on new terms.

What that means:

Offer transparency about your whereabouts.

Voluntarily. Before she asks.

"Heading to Dave's for the game. Should be home by 11."

Avoid staying out late.

Come home. Check in. Be present.

Even if she says she's fine with you going out.

You're rebuilding trust. Act like it.

Check in emotionally.

"How are you feeling about us? Do you need anything from me?"

Don't make her guess what you're thinking.

Don't get defensive when she has bad days.

She will. She'll have days where she's angry all over again.

Where she asks questions she's already asked.

Where she cries or pushes you away.

Don't take it personally. Just be there.

Therapy might be necessary.

Individual for you. Couples for both of you.

This isn't weakness. It's wisdom.

More on rebuilding after major betrayal: Infidelity recovery.

The Timeline You Should Expect

Here's what realistic reconciliation after infidelity looks like:

Weeks 1-4: Crisis mode

She's devastated. You're giving her space. No real communication.

Weeks 5-8: Initial contact

You apologize. She might rage. Or cry. Or both.

You listen. You don't defend. You accept her pain.

Weeks 9-12: Testing the waters

If she's open, you start light contact. Careful conversations.

She's watching your every move.

Months 4-6: Tentative reconnection

Maybe you see each other. Casual. No pressure.

She's evaluating whether she can do this.

Months 7-12: Rebuilding

If she decides to try, this is where the real work begins.

Transparency. Therapy. Constant reassurance.

Year 2+: Trust slowly returns

She stops checking your phone every day.

She doesn't panic when you're late.

She starts to believe you've changed.

That's the timeline if everything goes well.

Most relationships don't make it past month 3.

Are you ready for that?

When It's Not Going to Work

Sometimes, it's just not salvageable.

Signs she's done:

  • She's told you explicitly she can't forgive you
  • She's dating someone else
  • She's completely cut off contact and won't respond
  • She's told friends and family she's moving on
  • Months have passed with zero softening

If that's the case, the most respectful thing you can do is let her go.

Not because you don't love her.

Because you do.

And loving her means accepting that you hurt her too badly to fix.

More on knowing when to walk away: Should you get back together?

Your First Step

Remember, trust takes time to rebuild. Be patient. Be consistent. Be better.

Your first step? Give her space. The rest can wait.

Don't call. Don't text. Don't show up.

Just: disappear for 2-4 weeks minimum.

Use that time to do the internal work.

Figure out why you cheated. Own it. Start changing.

When you do reach out, it should be with a genuine apology. No expectations.

Then see if she's willing to talk.

If she is, follow this roadmap.

If she's not, respect that.

Either way, you do the work to become better.

Not just for her. For yourself.

And for whoever's next, if she doesn't come back.

This is hard.

Maybe the hardest thing you'll ever do.

But if you love her, you owe her this effort.

Even if it doesn't work out the way you hope.

Good luck.

Psst: Don't Make Another Move Until After You Use This Free Tool

Still love your ex? Get smart before you act.

This free tool gives you:

  • Custom advice for your situation
    • Clear next steps
      • Pitfalls to avoid

        No email required. Takes 30 seconds.

        TRY IT!

        By Michael Fulmer: Breakup expert with 14 years experience. Trained in Gottman Method Couples Therapy (Level 1 & 2.) Thousands helped worldwide. Creator of Breakup Dojo with 1,000+ members, and now UNFAZED (new release.) My advice works. Psychology obsessed. 10,000+ read my “Ex-Communication” newsletter. Need breakup help? I’m your guy.