You're here because you want to know whether they're coming back. Not idly — the not-knowing is the part that actually hurts, and a clear yes or no would let you stop bracing. That's the real thing you're after, and it's worth being straight about what a list of signs can and can't hand you toward it.
A few signals do carry real information, and they have one thing in common: they aren't subtle. If your ex has told you plainly they want to try again, that's information about what they want — believe it. If they've said it and then done what they said, over time and not just once, that counts for more than any single message. And it runs the other way just as firmly: if they've told you plainly it's over, or asked you not to contact them, or blocked you, that's information too. Believe it as much as you'd believe the other. None of these need a checklist. When something's unambiguous, it doesn't need decoding.
One exception. If they controlled you, belittled you, or frightened you, then them saying they want to try again isn't a sign to weigh — it can be part of how that pattern works. Talk to a domestic abuse service before you decide anything, including whether to reply. Your safety comes first.
The trouble is everything else. They asked how I'm doing. They liked an old photo. They've gone quiet for a week. They still haven't reached out — but that's probably just pride. Every one of these can be read as a sign they're coming back. Every one can just as easily be read as a sign they've moved on. That isn't because you haven't learned to read them properly. It's because none of them carries an answer to the question you're asking — you're supplying it, in whichever direction is easier to sit with.
Silence is the clearest case. When someone hasn't said they want you back, there's no hidden message in the not-saying to decode — not pride, not guilt, not fear holding them back. Those are stories that fit a blank exactly as well as "they're done" does, and a blank doesn't resolve by being watched. It carries no information in either direction. Any reading of it is something you're doing, not something it's telling you.
And building the case that they secretly want to come back is what can keep a person circling for a long time. Every neutral thing becomes evidence; every silence becomes not yet. The whole time, your recovery is running on their signals instead of your own life — and you can't steer by a weather vane you're also spinning.
Here's the part that's easy to miss: even a clear sign wouldn't settle the thing that sent you looking. Nobody can read the future off the present, and someone who means it today can change their mind — minds changing is part of how breakups happen in the first place. What's hard isn't the missing information. It's that the outcome was never yours to hold. A checklist that "confirmed" they were coming back wouldn't hand you control over whether they actually do; it'd just move the bracing to a new spot.
Living with the not-knowing is hard, and a rough stretch is part of this. But if it's more than that — if you're not sleeping, not eating, can't get through work, and can't see a version of yourself on the other side of this — that's past what a page can help with. See a doctor or a therapist, and tell someone close to you what's going on. If you're thinking about hurting yourself, don't wait: contact a crisis line or emergency services now.
The better question isn't will they come back. It's the one sitting underneath it: do you actually want this, and is it something worth reopening? That one's answerable, and it's yours to answer. If you want to work through it honestly — including the real possibility that the honest answer is no — start there: Should you get back together?
One test worth turning on yourself: if the things you're doing for yourself would lose their point the moment you knew for certain they were never coming back, they weren't recovery. They were a way of waiting for an answer. Do them because they're yours to do.
You don't need to watch for anything. If something's unambiguous, it'll reach you without being looked for, and you can believe it whichever way it points. Let the rest be what it is. And put your attention on the life that's actually in your hands — not as a move to bring them back, but because it's the part of this you can do something with.
By Michael Fulmer; writing about breakups and recovery since 2011. Trained in Gottman Method Couples Therapy (Level 1 & 2).